decentralized.ink

Bitcoin vs Ethereum

Which is more decentralized — Bitcoin or Ethereum? A side-by-side on consensus, nodes, clients and governance.

BitcoinEthereum
GradeB+B
TypeL1 · PoWL1 · PoS
Nakamoto coefficient~2–3*~3*
Node / validator set~20,000+ reachable full nodes~1M validators · many node operators
Clients / sequencerBitcoin Core dominant; alternatives existExec: Geth ~41%, Nethermind ~38%, Besu ~16% (improving)
GovernanceNo formal governance (BIP + social consensus)Off-chain rough consensus
Key riskMining-pool concentrationLido staking share; Geth client lead

Bitcoin B+

  • Largest reachable full-node set
  • No foundation / no on-chain governance to capture
  • Maximally credibly neutral
  • Mining hashpower concentrated in a few pools
  • Bitcoin Core client dominance

Ethereum B

  • ~1M validators across many operators
  • Improving client diversity (no client > 2/3)
  • Largest decentralized app ecosystem
  • Staking-pool concentration (Lido share)
  • Geth still the leading execution client

Bottom line

Unmatched on node-level and political decentralization; mining-pool concentration is the asterisk. Strong on breadth; the work left is reducing staking-pool and client concentration.